My Name Is Earl wasn't stolen

Writer loses court battle

A writer who claimed the sitcom My Name Is Earl was stolen from his idea has lost a lawsuit against America’s NBC network.

Mark Gable launched his legal action three years ago, alleging that the sitcom ripped off his script Karma, which he touted around to TV bosses in 1995.

According to the Hollywood Reporter, he claimed that like My Name Is Earl, his idea revolved around a lottery-winner who uses the money to make amends for past bad behaviour in order to get good karma.

But a Los Angeles district court judge dismissed the case after ruling that the two shows were not substantially similar.

The decision was made in February, but now an appeal court has upheld the ruling, saying: ‘The superficial points of comparison between Karma and Earl gleaned haphazardly from three seasons of the television series donot rise to the level of substantial similarity.’

Published: 19 Jun 2011

Today's comedy-on demand picks


It's the sort of content comedians have been pumping out from their spare rooms since lockdown began, now being given a wider audience (and hopefully some £££s) thanks to E4, which commissioned this compilation series.

Four episodes will air online at 9pm Tuesday nights, starting with this one, which features Stath Lets Flats star Jamie Demetriou, Lolly Adefope, Rosie Jones, and Australian award-winner Sam Campbell

Click for more suggestions

... including a new, free stand-up special from Funmbi Omotayo plus Standing Up For Sunny, an indie romcom about a loner with cerebral palsy who is roped into helping a comedian overcome her shyness.

We see you are using AdBlocker software. Chortle relies on advertisers to fund this website so it’s free for you, so we would ask that you disable it for this site. Our ads are non-intrusive and relevant. Help keep Chortle viable.