TV is running scared of edgy comedy

...admits BBC comedy chief

Television chiefs are shunning controversial comedy in the wake of the ‘Sachsgate’ backlash, the BBC’s head of comedy has admitted.

Simon Wilson, the acting controller of comedy, said broadcasters were sticking with programmes they felt ‘safe’ with, following the furore over the phone calls made by Jonathan Ross and Russell Brand.

The BBC subsequently drew up guidelines restricting comedy shows featuring ‘derogatory remarks’.

In this week’s Radio Times, Wilson said: ‘Comedy ought to be risky – that’s what makes it funny – but in tough times channel controllers want stuff they feel safe with.’

His comments came as John Lloyd, the producer behind Not The Nine O’Clock News, Blackadder and QI, accused commissioners of being too scared of complaints.

He said: ‘You get this constant swing between puritanism and the desire to push things as far as they can go: what I call cavaliers v roundheads.

‘When we did Not the Nine o’Clock News the BBC really wanted young, edgy talent on screen and when we got 30 complaints the head of department said any decent satire show would have got 60.

‘These days broadcasters aren’t commissioning brave comedy because they’re far too worried about the risk.’

He added that the economic crisis may also have changed attitudes in comedy.

‘In a recession people want cheering up. If you look at cruel satire, it always does better in boom times like the 60s or 80s. Michael McIntyre and Frankie Boyle are both very funny, but they have to be seen in the right time and place.’

Published: 3 Dec 2009

Today's comedy-on demand picks


The comedian and rapper is putting his 2017 Edinburgh Fringe show out on YouTube for free.

In it, he likens the human lifespan to a banana, from green and full of potential to the black mush of decay; looking back at childhood crazes such as Pogs and considering his mental health today.

Click for more suggestions
... including a new podcast in which comedians describe their ideal music festival line-ip and two full improvised musicals from Showstopper!

We see you are using AdBlocker software. Chortle relies on advertisers to fund this website so it’s free for you, so we would ask that you disable it for this site. Our ads are non-intrusive and relevant. Help keep Chortle viable.