The Defiant Thomas Brothers

Note: This review is from 2005

Review by Steve Bennett

One member of this comedy double act is black, the  other white. Imagine, two people of different colours being friends. Wow!

It certainly looks like they are going to overplay this angle. We come in to the strains of ‘the page is white, the ink is black…’ the first sketch is about the word ‘nigger’ and  even the clothes  they wear on stage  mix black and white. And look at the publicity photo above.

Thankfully they don’t push through with this theme any further. But they don’t push through with much that’s funny, either.

They are, clearly, very good performers able to produce a wide range of rounded character sketches, subtle in the way they speak and act, and sharply observed so they become vividly real.

But the fact that few sketches use their acting skills to find laughs makes the whole endeavour seem more like an audition piece than a complete show in its  own right. They’re just showing casting agents what they can do – the Saturday Night Live writers’ room can always make them funny later.

Certainly this show impressed the great and the good of America’s TV industry at the Aspen Comedy Arts Festival  this year, where they were named best sketch group. Perhaps their upbeat song ‘We don’t sing about Jews’ swung it for them. But they didn’t impress their sparse Edinburgh audience quite so much, judging  by the number of folded arms.

Two sketches do stand out, however. In the first, a dad dispenses sage fatherly advice entirely in bizarre similies – ‘marriage , son, is like a urine sample’ – while a second  is an take on the old ‘Who’s on first base’ routine, updated to revolve around drug dealers and their street names.

These are both brilliant, but mostly the pieces are overlong and  under-amusing. Having established their characters so effectively, the duo just leave them there time and time again for us to admire,  rather than have something funny happen to them.

It’s hard to see what exactly these Thomas Brothers are  defying, other than the rule that says you need laughs in comedy.

Review date: 1 Jan 2005
Reviewed by: Steve Bennett

What do you think?

Today's comedy-on demand picks

NICK HELM: ALL KILLER SOME FILLER

This is the show that celebrated the launch of Nick Helm's album in 2016, and has previously been unseen by anyone who was not in the O2 Forum Kentish Town that night.

With typical hyperbole, the show is described thusly: 'Under-rehearsed, under-prepared and under pressure, Nick and his band somehow managed to pull together the greatest show in the last 27 years of living memory. That show went down as a thing of legend, often spoken about by weary travellers around campfires, but thought to have been lost to the sands of time forever.'

Click for more suggestions

... including Al Murray headlining a Just For Tonic gig and the launch of Free Festival's virtual comedy programming.

We see you are using AdBlocker software. Chortle relies on advertisers to fund this website so it’s free for you, so we would ask that you disable it for this site. Our ads are non-intrusive and relevant. Help keep Chortle viable.