LIVE COMEDY SEARCH

Search Shows

Charlie Chuck Is Scrooge

Charlie Chuck Is Scrooge

Show type: Edinburgh Fringe 2002

Or is he? Reeves and Mortimer's sidekick returns after 5 years with this surreal esoteric quontro mechanics tale of Scrooge. Did he exist? Does Charlie exist? Find out if you exist. Woof Bark Donkey.

Comedians

Starring Charlie Chuck

Reviews

Original Review:

With his fragmented manner, Tourette-ish outbursts and compelling physical tics, Charlie Chuck's inspired lunacy is a welcome novelty - but is it enough to sustain an entire show?

Unfortunately, judging from this mess, the answer is a resounding no.

Obviously, being shambolic is all part of Chuck's unique appeal - but this overstretched idea takes it to painful new lows.

While no one would expect this to be the most faithful of renditions of Dickens's work, there comes a point when the endearing nature of the sheer amateurishness wears off, and it just becomes embarrassing and frustrating.

It's a disappointment as it all starts so well. The first ten minutes are excellent, with Chuck in fine form manically barking out non-sequiteurs - and mouthfuls of half-digested Sugar Puffs - to glorious effect.

But then it descends into a shoddy, ill-prepared mess. At first, the mistimed cues, forgotten lines and corpsing is funny, but it soon wears very thin. It's a 15-minute idea shameless padded to fill the time.

There were some die-hard fans in the audience, lapping up every awkward inadequacy, but too often this all felt like a private joke between the performers and their guffawing admirers.

Chuck's madness really needs something sober to react against - but with everything collapsing into chaos, it simply becomes irritating, and you long for something resembling a plot or a joke.

The joyously stupid song-and-dance finale goes some way to repairing the damage, but to be honest, by then I'd lost the will to laugh.

Comments

Older Comments

Show Dates