Edinburgh Fringe 2000 (59)
Edinburgh Fringe 2001 (316)
Edinburgh Fringe 2002 (354)
Edinburgh Fringe 2003 (376)
Edinburgh Fringe 2004 (422)
Edinburgh Fringe 2005 (415)
Edinburgh Fringe 2006 (547)
Edinburgh Fringe 2007 (668)
Edinburgh Fringe 2008 (733)
Edinburgh Fringe 2009 (773)
Edinburgh Fringe 2010 (927)
Edinburgh Fringe 2011 (963)
Edinburgh Fringe 2012 (1022)
Edinburgh Fringe 2013 (740)
Melbourne 2005 (26)
Melbourne 2006 (29)
Melbourne 2007 (31)
Melbourne 2008 (36)
Melbourne 2009 (36)
Melbourne 2010 (56)
Melbourne 2011 (36)
Melbourne 2012 (46)
Melbourne 2013 (57)
Misc live shows (204)
Montreal 2004 (6)
Montreal 2006 (10)
Montreal 2007 (15)
Montreal 2008 (17)Montreal 2009 (17)
West End run (14)
See Less »
The Emerald Isle’s greatest wits travel across the pond to serve up a night of brilliant blather and blarney. Whether you’re a wee bit Irish or a full fledged paddy, it’s Celtic comedy beyond compare.
Original Review:If you were looking for a theme to unite most of the Irish comedians on this showcase, it would have to be their sexually inadequacy.
Three of the four acts spoke frankly of their failings in the bedroom, and given that no one – with the possible exception of the Welsh – does self-deprecation like the Irish, it made for some ludicrously entertaining anecdotes.
Compere Neil Delamer had the best of them, with his hilarious tale of humiliation at the hands of a statuesque Icelandic beauty. His unexpected delight at talking her into bed turned to brilliant farce, as the daunting practicalities of the situation become slowly apparent.
It’s a brilliant routine, like something from the best Farrelly Brothers movie, building slowly but methodically to its preposterously embarrassing climax; the comedy of the situation heightened by the contrast between his bumbling amiability and her clinical Nordic approach.
Delamere’s long had the effortless geniality that makes him the perfect host, but only recently has his conversational material started to catch up. His stories – of which he is almost always the butt – might start modestly, but they are constructed with the precision of a structural engineer, so a tale about diving with sharks that starts out as a pedestrian mockery of the ridiculous advice given in case of attack builds on those solid foundations into another impressive side-splitter.
The first act, the much-vaunted John Lynn, only three years into his stand-up career, is some way behind Delamere in evolving his material. This likeable ex-teacher has a winning physicality, skilfully re-enacting keenly-observed scenes from domestic life, but it’s only fitfully amusing.
Perhaps the sticking point is that his vignettes are just a little too realistic. When he recreates a girlfriend’s drunkenly argumentative behaviour, it’s with an impressive accuracy, so it’s not so much a joke as a reconstruction. So after he’s got the immediate laugh of recognition, he hasn’t much more to offer as the scene plays out, however articulate his descriptions.
Elsewhere he moans about the ‘little bastards’ for whom he had to feign concern in the classroom, and joins in with the sexual inadequacy confessionals, writing uncomfortably around on the stool to demonstrate the effects of his technique. It’s the only time he does look uncomfortable on the stage, which seems like his second home, but he could do with more substance to support his undeniable poise.
David O’Doherty floundered uncharacteristically at the start of his set, with an ill-advised choice of opening material. A windy routine about his brother’s technical difficulties with a computer seemed more like a distracted diversion than an introduction to his distinctive approach.
However preposterous potted history of Ireland, based on the over-marketed leprechaun and St Patrick mythology, started to break the ice, and he slowly began to build up a head of steam.
Although the ever-charming O’Doherty has been keen to cultivate the ‘whimsy’ angle, his low-fi delivery actually conceals some sharp, well-constructed gags and routines that even the slickest comic could use. Putting these into play, albeit belatedly, allowed him to build momentum.
His badger routine is an hilarious delight – yet another animal-attack story with a twist taking it well out of hack territory; the ill-judged popcorn prank is beautifully described; and the anecdote about waking up after a rare night on the beer is a quirky winner, far from the laddish drink-related war stories you can hear every weekend at Jongleurs.
The Beefs 2008 song on which he closed packed in the punchlines about his petty pet hates, more than compensating for his faltering start. Accompanied by his signature cheap keyboard, this witty ditty allowed him to end as strongly as his originality and talent deserve.
After the interval, Jason Byrne was unleashed, starting off with the affectionate, crowd-pleasing knocking of Quebec’s French speakers and ice-hockey obsession. In many ways, it’s standard local material but, as always with Byrne, it’s the maniacal fervour that holds the secret; the sheer passion with which he runs, bit between his teeth, into hilariously exaggerated indignity.
He’s a physical performer, prowling the stage like a psychotic T-Rex to prove an untenable point or rushing around like a dervish with an edge of dangerous unpredictability. That this unhinged wild man of comedy is not shackled to a unyielding script only adds to that liberating feel, as he’ll improvise wildly around anything that catches his attention-deficient eye.
The stage persona that of a man on the precipice of madness. But it’s also presented as this is the only possible reaction to an already insane world. Like Basily Fawlty before him, he has been driven to the edge by the relentless frustration that reality doesn’t fit his platonic ideal. Everyone, in short, is wrong but him.
In fact, he often paints a gothically dark picture of life, oppressed by the stifling forces of marriage, responsibility and an overbearing Catholic upbringing. He depicts all the human faces of these factors – from his wife to a priest – as gruesome grotesques. On these topics, his delivery becomes almost demonic, so it’s no surprise when his troubled imagination pictures Santa Claus killed in a bloody, brutal accident; the incongruity of the image, of course, proving hilarity.
With all that baggage, no wonder he escapes the grinding misery of existence through childish pranks and arsing about on stage. The hero of his stories is either his eight-year-old son – or his own immaturity, forever striking a blow against all the inflexible, misery-guts whose mundanity contrast so starkly with his own untethered dreams.
But surely no one could ever be glum after his typhoon of a performance. He is an unstoppable force of nature, wreaking a trail of comic destruction. Resistance is futile.
Reviewed by: Steve Bennett
No comments are currently available for this show.
Jason Byrne: The Lovely Goat Show
David O'Doherty Is My Name
Jason Byrne: Sheep For Feet And Rams For Hands
David O'Doherty in World Champion of Some Things
Jason Byrne: That's Not A Badger
David O'Doherty Creates Something New Under The Su
Jason Byrne Hates...
David O'Doherty: Small Things
Brighton Comedy Festival 2010 opening gala
Brighton Comedy Festival: Best Of The Fest
Carlsberg Comedy Carnival 2009
Channel 4 Comedy Gala 2011
Leicester Comedy Festival Preview Show 2008
Pecha Kucka KLK with David O'Doherty
A Film With Me In It
David O'Doherty: It's David O'Doherty Time
Jason Byrne: Shy Pigs With Wigs Hidden In Twigs
Jason Byrne’s Telly Idea, Which May Also Work On The Radio…Show
Neil Delamere: The Viking Show
Jason Byrne: Out Of The Box
Adam, Jason & Friends
David O'Doherty: Let's Comedy
Honourable Men Of Art 2008
I Can't Sleep by David O'Doherty
Jason Byrne: Cats Under Mats Having Chats With Bats
Neil Delamere: Crème Delamere
The Alternative Show
Jimmy Fallon Gala
Adam, Jason & Friends 
David O'Doherty: David O' Doh-party
Jason Byrne: The Byrne Supremacy
Neil Delamere: Bookmarks
I Can't Sleep
David O'Doherty: Somewhere Over The David O'Doherty
Jason Byrne 2010
David O'Doherty Is Looking Up
David O'Doherty Presents: Rory Sheridan's Tales Of The Antarctica
Jason Byrne: Cirque Du Byrne
Neil Delamere: Divilment
David O'Doherty Presents 403 Second Masterworks
David O'Doherty: Seize The David O'Doherty
Jason Byrne: People's Puppeteer
Mark Watson's Edinborolympics
Neil Delamere: DelaMere Mortal
Comedy Gala In Aid Of Waverley Care 2013
David O'Doherty Will Try to Fix Everything
Jason Byrne's Special Eye
Neil Delamere: Smartbomb