Edinburgh Fringe 2000 (16)
Edinburgh Fringe 2001 (29)
Edinburgh Fringe 2002 (34)
Edinburgh Fringe 2003 (30)
Edinburgh Fringe 2004 (38)
Edinburgh Fringe 2005 (39)
Edinburgh Fringe 2006 (70)
Edinburgh Fringe 2007 (57)
Edinburgh Fringe 2008 (65)
Edinburgh Fringe 2009 (65)
Melbourne 2012 (2)
See Less »
John Scott Is Totally Made Up
In 2003 John was runner up in the Spike Milligan Award. He thought he’d done better and so did the audience, but that’s competitions for you. From there he vowed never to get involved in comedy competitions again...
John Scott is Totally Made Up
I’ve absolutely no idea what the Spike Milligan award was, but John Scott was runner-up in it in 2003. And last year he won £12,000 in a brewer’s Take The Mic competition for Scottish acts. According to his tongue-in-cheek blurb, that makes him ‘multi-award-winning’.
What judges saw in him, is less clear, as this is an hour of competently delivered but mostly dull stand-up, with no little creativity and no ambition.
An opening joke is about a gig in Wigan where the audience was full of people with ‘shaved heads and no neck and…’ wait for it… ‘that was just the women!’ You could forgive a tediously easy ice-breaker, I suppose, but I can’t see how any comedian could be proud of saying a line like this, and it’s not the only time he uses the device.
Nor does the material strive for anything original. He’s still not only doing jokes about the 2007 terrorist attacks on Glasgow Airport – but the very same joke people where cracking at the very moment the news broke: Glaswegians will punch someone even if they are on fire.
Other keen observations from his 41 years on earth include the fact that poor people wear tracksuits even though they don’t do any exercise, Glaswegians use the c-word like punctuation – and sometimes he finds himself wandering into the kitchen and wondering what he came in for. I got a similar feeling after walking into his show.
He admits his section on the differences between the genders is ‘the thing comedians have been talking about forever’, then offers up absolutely nothing on the topic. Imagining that men would have a different approach to pregnancy is as far as it gets and it’s lazy, lazy stuff.
Occasionally he transcends this with some anecdote unique to him. The holiday to Egypt offers up a funny moment when he’s told how to get through a checkpoint, he’s got a couple of scary heckler stories, and the recreation of one of his potentially offensive sketch character has a lot of fun to it that’s absent from the rest of the hour.
This is a very pedestrian set from a comic who just doesn’t seem to be trying.
|Date of live review: Thursday 25th Aug, '11|
Review by Steve Bennett
I must have been at a different show to Mr Bennett as I and my fellow audience members found it entertaining and amusing. It was a packed house and everyone seemed to enjoyed it, thanks goodness I don't listen to critics or I would have missed out on a very enjoyable hour of comedy.