Show Details
Die Roten Punkte
Show type: Melbourne 2006

Die Roten Punkte


+
Description

This show has not yet got a description.

+
Reviews

Original Review:

It’s an odd beast, this musical parody of the White Stripes. Not only did Clare Bartholomew and Daniel Tobias decide to make their band inexplicably German, they then decided to ignore most of the possibilities for comedy in their original idea.

All really that remains is the incestuous relationship between drummer Astrid and her sibling guitarist Otto, mirroring the ambiguity that Jack and Meg White once exploited for worldwide publicity.

But this isn’t done with a great deal of subtlety as their increasingly acrimonious sibling rivalry releases their barely-repressed passion, until they are writhing on the floor together in forbidden lust.

That’s really the extent of the joke, padded out over almost 50 minutes despite the obvious inevitability. They try to make up for the paucity of inspiration by bringing a pounding, shouty energy in their songs - but it just converts their obvious amateurism into enthusiastic amateurism.

What gags there are come from their vicious competitiveness, each of them, for instance, vying to have the last chord in a particularly longwinded track, but otherwise they are simply loud and brash.

Their music, which is created by miniature toy instruments, isn’t a close spoof of the White Strips, more an encapsulation of their rock spirit. They are light on lyrics, which limits the capacity for jokes - not that this duo seem particularly adept at writing them – and the tracks are repetitve. Even in this mercifully short show, their theme tune, boasting a full two lines of lyrics, is played twice – just enough for the admittedly catchy hook to burrow its way into your brain.

As a ten-minute slot, Die Roten Punkte (which translates as The Red Dots) would do fine, with the exuberance of their physical and musical performance enough to see see them through. But it’s all very light for a full-length show.

Die Roten Punkte? Nein danke

Reviewed by: Steve Bennett
May 2006

+
Comments

I've just seen Die Roten Punkte again at the Melbourne Comedy Festival and they totally rock! I don't see that they are trying to emulate the White Stripes as this reviewer claims, they are a brother sister band with fantastic songs - there's the comparison (what a good one too) and they are one of the finer original acts here at this festival. My fave show so far.

Dean Bradley, April 2009


Ditto as above. I saw this act at The Falls Festival this year and recently at The Adelaide Fringe. Their songs are awesome and their on-stage presence is electric. Their new show is fantastic, very funny. I don't think they are trying in any way to "BE" the White Stripes. They certainly don;t reference them in any way, so I'm not sure where the reviewer got that from? They just are brother and sister with mini instruments. I wear my I'm In A Band hoodie with pride!

Mark Sheehan, April 2008


Clearly this reviewer doesn't get the joke. Punk music is repetitive and that's one of the (many) reasons why this act is so funny. perhaps he got them on a bad night but having seen their show at least three times now I fine it more hilarious each time. Also, they're not trying to portray the White Stripes at all, I think the brother sister act was merely inspiration.

Sophie Young, January 2008



Have your say:
:
:
: