Chortle : The Uk Comedy Guide
 Find live comedy in:  :  Comedians | Shows 

Subscribe
 
Francesca Martinez: I'Mperfect Show type: Edinburgh Fringe 2002
Francesca Martinez: I'Mperfect

Show Rating:Francesca Martinez: I'Mperfect rated 3/5

Most of us are defined by what we can do, not what we can't. Unless, of course, you're disabled.

That, at least theoretically, is the enticing premise behind Francesca Martinez's first full-length show. She's an actor whose appeared in Grange Hill, an award-winning stand-up and a writer - but these descriptions are always qualified by the adjective 'disabled'

This actually presents something of a dilemma. Having something that sets you apart from society is a boon for any stand-up. But in talking about her cerebral palsy, wouldn't she be perpetuating the billing of 'disabled comedian', rather than just plain 'comedian'?

It's a quandry that isn't satisfactorily resolved here. Of course she addresses the issue, but she also presents some traditional stand-up routines making no reference to it.

Sadly, these sections are quite pedestrian - perhaps for the very reason that they don't have that personal edge that makes the material about living with a disability so unique. Most comics could come up with a routine about advertising and branding to match Martinez's observations on the topic. But none could talk about the way people react to disabled people the way she does.

So half the show is incisive, personal and funny, the rest lacklustre and generic. And, though padded by a couple of sketches and an entertaining finale in which some reckless punter volunteers to let Martinez cut his hair, there isn't enough substance to justify a full hour.

Martinez used to joke that her full-length show was simply her brilliant 20-minute routine, but she walked to and from the microphone on her own. That could be a bit too close to the mark

Review by Steve Bennett
 
Starring Comic: Francesca Martinez

This comic also appears in: The Comedy Zone Francesca Martinez In Deep

 E-mail | About Us | Terms 158,144 unique users in August. Currently listing 3,316 upcoming events Copyright ©2008 Chortle 
This website and all original content copyright is © Chortle 2000-2008, all rights reserved. Site designed and created at Powder Blue in association with Chortle.