Shirley & Shirley: Not Just A One Night Stand | Gig review by Steve Bennett at the Museum Of Comedy

Shirley & Shirley: Not Just A One Night Stand

Gig review by Steve Bennett at the Museum Of Comedy

In their preamble, Shirley & Shirley promise characters, sketches and something called ‘scene studies’, which seems a bit drama-schooly.

Indeed, Not Just A One Night Stand showcases their acting talents, thought they shine when they throw any ideas of portraying a normality out of the window and plump for brash, odd sketches,which are given the hard sell by the pair’s commitment to the absurd.

Funniest is the unpromising idea of a man with a robot partner that indulges his every fantasy, which turns out to be a stock mix of football, curry and cars. But the execution makes it: Pascale Wilson’s deadpan automaton contrasted with Joanna Carolan’s grubby excitement, a typically energetic performance that doesn’t hold back

It’s one of several scenes that depict a jaded view of relationships, also seen in an emotionally sterile rich couple, or the pair making a meal of eating out, over-pronouncing the florid adjectives on the menu. Weddings are included in that cynicism, too, courtesy of a speech from an embittered mother of the bride, begrudging the money spent on the bash.

The landscape is usually in the cosmopolitan middle-class, epitomised in an an opening sketch about posh women whose cheeky glasses of wine hide a raging alcoholism. It seems like a calling card – they ask how many people in the audience have seen it before – though it’s none too ambitious, especially when compared to their more outrageous scenarios.

They return to this drinking theme later, with a more entertainingly peculiar edge, as Wilson’s gregarious Frenchwoman Celine gets increasing sloshed with the ‘soupcons’ of wine she glugs. And more Continental oddness comes through their bizarre German avant-garde sketch that’s amusingly baffling. Like many of the scenes here, it struggles for a punchline, and rather peters out – but the journey is fun, and  Wilson and  Carolan clearly have a strong, instinctual chemistry.

But it’s a little hard to get a handle on the Shirley & Shirley as their tone is ever-shifting. And for all that just being strange is fun, there’s sometimes a need for stronger writing to underpin the compelling performances, especially when they use old tropes like dropping their normal well-spoken accents for street patios or high-energy rapping. 

With six Edinburgh Fringes behind them (although they haven’t been for a couple of years), it feels like Shirley and Shirley are due a break. But they   missing extra element that would make them a must-see, rather than just enjoyable when you do  Still, they can easily lay claim to being the best Irish-Palestinian, Surinamese-Croydonian female double act on the circuit

• Shirley & Shirley: Not Just A One Night Stand is at the Museum of Comedy at 8.45pm nightly until Friday.

Review date: 19 Oct 2016
Reviewed by: Steve Bennett

What do you think?

Live comedy picks

We see you are using AdBlocker software. Chortle relies on advertisers to fund this website so it’s free for you, so we would ask that you disable it for this site. Our ads are non-intrusive and relevant. Help keep Chortle viable.