Robert Newman: No Planet B

Note: This review is from 2006

Review by Steve Bennett

Fans of Robert Newman who’ve stuck with him through his reinvention pretty much know what to expect from him by now: dense, socio-political doom-mongering, enlivened by gags and impressions, with a bit of ukulele playing thrown in.

Well, No Planet B, despite the apocalyptic connotations of its title, is something of a departure - mainly in that the anti-corporate drum-banging is played down. And there’s more ukulele. A lot more.

The premise is that as 2006 marks the end of our unsustainable civilisation, Newman will play out human history in reverse. Thus in 1900 American Indians begin a process of ethnic cleansing, ‘so relentless and ruthless that by 1492 there is not one single European living on the North American landmass’ or Nelson Mandela enters prison ‘a sweet-natured Spice Girl fan’ but emerges ‘an embittered terrorist bent on the armed overthrow of the state’.

It’s a brilliant, inspired comic device; and every good joke in the show emerges from applying this unique concept, brilliant in being both hugely ambitious yet simple to grasp.

Furthermore, it raises fundamental questions about the very nature of progress. Planes are taken out of the sky to reduce global warming, corporations are disbanded to encourage local enterprise and the world becomes a simpler, more pleasant place to live.

Of course, there are drawbacks, too. As inventions become un-invented, X-rays, radio and international phone calls become impossible. And, in the best routine of the night, the suffragette movement campaign to lose the hassle of having to work and vote, and instead stay, unpressured, at home.

Newman seems to yearn for the past, and not just as a kickback against the iniquities and environmental cataclysm of capitalism. He belongs in a different age, a travelling troubadour who wants only to wander between small settlements, entertaining with his tales, jokes and songs. This is a show that would be best performed around an intimate campfire, the music – in which he is accompanied by Diego Brown and The Good Fairy – only adds to this seductive mood.

It suits Newman, who doesn’t really fit into any modern category of entertainer. No Planet B is not really comedy, nor theatre, nor a political lecture, nor a folk music gig. Rather it combines elements of them all – and not always successfully.

While the central comic conceit is unbeatable, it’s surrounded by all manner of peripheral business that detracts from it, rather than enhancing it.

Chief among these is a sub-plot about a romance between a couple known as John and Teresa, played out against the background of war in Europe and reaching a denouement in the 1937 Guernica bombardment of the Spanish Civil War, the first (or last, with Newman’s reversed arrow of time) targeting of civilian populations in war.

The love story unfolds over the centuries, with Thomas Hardy, William Shakespeare and Jesus - here a South American itinerant worker - all contributing chapters. Quite how it fits in with the main thrust of the show, though, is debatable.

The second half of the show, especially, gets bogged down in this, and Newman’s more literary aspirations, losing the comic momentum carefully built up in the first.

As mankind finally grows weary of the land, loses its intelligence and crawls back into the ocean’s depths from whence we came, you can’t help thinking: ‘Is that it?"

Like modern human civilisation itself, a show that started out so promisingly, so full of passion and ideas, got a little bit lost somewhere along the way.

Review date: 1 Jan 2006
Reviewed by: Steve Bennett

What do you think?

Live comedy picks

We see you are using AdBlocker software. Chortle relies on advertisers to fund this website so it’s free for you, so we would ask that you disable it for this site. Our ads are non-intrusive and relevant. Help keep Chortle viable.