Stand-up comedian George Ryegold at Chortle's Fast Fringe

Clip from 2009 Edinburgh Fringe show

More George Ryegold videos

George Ryegold: Fringe 2012
Live Review
Underbelly Bristo Square

There are some cracking lines in the play created around George Ryegold’s stand-up persona – even if the actual piece is heavily flawed.

It’s less a play and more a sitcom episode, with limited locations and every character ending where they began. And there’s a very good reason why sitcoms stick to twentysomething minutes, over an hour the plot and characterisations offer thin pickings indeed, certainly in this case.

The exception is Ryegold himself, the alter-ego Toby Williams has had years to inhabit on the stand-up scene. He’s a sleazy, stingy, gloomy, tweedy doctor, with an unhealthily causal approach to some of the workings of the human body. Tellingly, his best lines come when he’s addressing an audience –  either a conference of his scientific colleagues or a school sex education lesson – belying his stand-up roots.

Comics fill up the cast, too. Ryegold’s professional nemesis Dr Strode is played by Milo McCabe, who does his best, but there’s not much a character to sink his teeth into: a posh ‘Oh, yahoo’ stereotype with sweater tossed casually around his shoulders and an arrogant, swagger of entitlement.

Ryegold has a love interest, a teacher played by Lindsay Sharman – though quite why she has so little in her favour that she is interested in this penny-pinching grump is never explained for this paper-thin character – while The Trap’s Dan Mersh amiably plays generic flatmate, a dim but easy-going foil for Ryegold’s misanthropy. Hattie Hayridge is underused as the owner of the local café where they all hang out, demonstrating that dour world-weariness she has made her own.

Essentially the plot involves Ryegold having to make the big conference speech, without having any ideas. The bully Strode is piling on the pressure, while Ryegold is keen to show him up as a charlatan. It sounds very much like a Radio 4 sitcom – and securing one may well be his aim – just not a very good one, and a bit more ‘adult’.

The jeopardy and tensions are slight – just enough to get Ryegold from one set piece to the next. The writing of individual lines can be exquisite, with a real twist and elegantly precise use of language,  but other parts of the dialogue seem flat. And as an overall script it doesn’t work.

There are maybe a dozen fantastic lines, here – but at one every five minutes, it’s not a great rate when the storyline isn’t absorbing enough to make up for it.

Every time I see George perform I realise I still have a long way to go. His timing, delivery and rapport with the audience are spot on. A really funny and likable guy.

Kevin M, September 2009

Go see this show! George is amazing. Witty writing. Flawless delivery. And more than that he just tickles you in the places you won't expect. I saw him doing 20s many times over the last year and he never fell short of extraordinary. But yesterday at the Lion's Den was the first time i saw him doing the whole hour and i was stunned and impressed! Wonderful job! He is a joy to watch. George is the comics' favorite. He is very original act, he's got intelligent material, the amount of research he puts in it is awe-inspiring, and he is immensely talented. One of the few true gems of this year's Fringe. Trust me guys I'm very picky. George won't disappoint you. He knocks down barriers, breaks molds and pushes envelopes to the bursting limits of what is allowed to be said, but at the same time he doesn't just exploit filth, sex, swearing or rudeness - he's a true artist with the finesse of a scalpel.

Denis Krasnov, August 2009